Talk:Whitefish Bay

Body of water article? Region article?
A nice start on this article but there is a little problem: we don't do articles on bodies of water unless they represent a clearly defined land region, usually as a region article which is part of a region breakdown. This article, however is so far set up kind of like a city page, yet one of the listings here actually belongs at Paradise (Michigan), since we don't duplicate listings. I think a decision needs to be made here: either We can't really do both. So which should it be? Texugo (talk) 02:00, 9 August 2014 (UTC)
 * this article should be treated as a conglomerate city article including Paradise and Brimley etc.,in which case Paradise needs to be merged and redirected here, or
 * general info on the bay itself needs to be covered in Upper Peninsula and specific listings need to be covered in the specific articles like Paradise (Michigan) and Brimley
 * There's basically nothing listed for Paradise MI on that page; you have turned that article into a w:WP:HATRACK to cover primarily Whitefish Point. I strongly disagree and have moved this to Paradise and Whitefish Bay to cover the entire large rural area instead of just one village with no local listings. K7L (talk) 03:04, 4 November 2016 (UTC)